A Caltech-led team using LIGO, Virgo, and KAGRA data thinks a large share of merging black holes may have been born when massive stars failed to explode as supernovas, Space.com reports. The usual picture is a core collapse that triggers a supernova, with the leftover core becoming a black hole. This work, published November 10, 2026 in Physical Review D, looks at the mass and spin of 257 black hole mergers from the past decade and finds a sharp pile-up around 10 solar masses, about 75% of the sample, plus a scarcity of black holes between about 12 and 16 solar masses. Those 10-solar-mass objects also appear to share a distinct range of spin speeds, which the team reads as a hint of a common origin.
The researchers are careful, and I will be too. There is still no direct observation of a failed supernova, though theory has long allowed stars to implode quietly. Caltech’s write-up says the study did not find direct evidence for failed supernovas, but that the gravitational-wave record matches what theorists had predicted for such a population. Isaac Legred, the lead author, said the data are consistent with most binary black holes forming that way, and that more research is needed.
My take
I like a paper that ties a bump in the data to a formation story and then admits the story is not proven yet. If most of the black holes we hear colliding are the leftovers of stars that never made a firework, that is a quieter universe than the one in the textbooks, and it is still a preliminary read.
God Bless, and Use the Source!