God

Modernity Is Seeking a Hypergood, and James Eglinton Says It’s Making Us Miserable

Leave a comment

James Eglinton, writing for The Gospel Coalition, takes Charles Taylor’s idea of the “hypergood” and shows why so many of us feel crushed by things that were supposed to make life work. In Sources of the Self, Taylor argues that nobody stands outside a moral framework, and that modern Western people tend to treat the self as a moral source: “I am a good person because I say so.” We also rank our goods. One of them has to sit at the top, because that highest good is what we use to justify ourselves and then measure whether our lives measure up. The catch, Eglinton says, is how we pick that highest good. We take a finite, ordinary good and ask it to play the role of an ultimate one. Read next to Augustine’s distinction between use and enjoyment, that move is a form of idolatry. It overburdens the thing we elevate, neglects the goods we push aside, and sets us at odds with other people and with ourselves.

Only when the ultimate place belongs to God, he writes, can ordinary goods be freed to be what they are. You will be a better friend if the approval of your group is not your hypergood. You will be a better student if achievement is not your hypergood. You will be a better citizen if your nation is not your hypergood. Augustine’s line is that to enjoy something is to rest in it for its own sake, and in that sense the only true object of enjoyment is God himself. He is not a means to an end. In him there is “ultimate enoughness,” and created things can finally be good without having to be God.

My take

This is a word I needed. The Holy Spirit keeps exposing the same old trade: we ask a gift to do the Giver’s job, then wonder why it breaks in our hands. “My people have exchanged their glorious God for worthless idols” is not only an ancient headline (Jeremiah 2:11-13). If you have been exhausting a career, a reputation, or even a good relationship by making it the thing that has to save you, the invitation is not to despise those gifts. It is to enjoy the Lord first, and then let them be gifts again. “You make known to me the path of life; you will fill me with joy in your presence” (Psalm 16:11).

God Bless, and May the Source Be with You!

References & Further Reading

Subscribe (RSS) Follow God via RSS

Leave a note

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.