Thomas West, writing for The Gospel Coalition, reviews Gavin Ortlund’s Why Christianity Makes Sense, a readable case for why it is reasonable to follow Jesus, aimed at people who are not sure the faith can survive hard questions, and at believers who keep running into those questions online. Ortlund, known for his Truth Unites ministry, treats the questions as more than a debate club. They come from a deeper longing for meaning, purpose, and transcendence, what he calls “the ache.” West connects that to Paul’s stop in Athens, where the apostle noticed an altar “to an unknown god” and used it as a door, not a punchline (Acts 17:23). Augustine called it the restless heart. Lewis called it Sehnsucht. Keller called the traces it leaves clues.
Ortlund points readers to Jesus’s own claims: He did not merely point to a path, He pointed to Himself as the way, the truth, and the life. The claim is preposterous unless it is true. West also highlights Ortlund’s treatment of divine hiddenness, the honest question of why, if God is real, He is not more obvious, especially for people whose unanswered prayers have stacked up. Drawing on Pascal, Ortlund argues that a partial revelation is not a defect in Christian theology; it is part of the drama of a God who comes near and still asks for humility. The biggest problem is not ignorance, West notes, quoting the book’s through-line. It is sin. The book is a more accessible companion to Ortlund’s earlier Why God Makes Sense in a World That Doesn’t, with reflection questions that work for a college student or a small group.
My take
I have not sat down with every chapter, but this is the kind of clear, public witness I want more of. The Holy Spirit still uses the ache in a human heart, and He still uses people who will reason in the modern marketplace without shrinking Jesus to a hobby. “Come, all you who are thirsty, come to the waters” (Isaiah 55:1). If someone you love is asking whether Christianity can actually make sense, this looks like a book worth putting in their hands, and then praying they meet the Person it is about, not just the argument.
God Bless, and May the Source Be with You!