Andrew Wilson’s Gospel Coalition review of Tim Whitmarsh’s Rome’s Age of Revolution: Augustus, Empire, and the Making of Christianity is cooler than the blurbs. The dust jacket talks as if the book redefines early Christianity. Wilson says what you actually get is a clear, well-written presentation of a widely held view: the church was shaped by the Greek and Roman world that incubated it, including the impact of Augustus’ political reforms, and a lot of that thesis is not new.
Wilson is at his fairest when he describes the parts that help. Roman roads, citizenship, letters, and a shared sense of a new age made the gospel easier to carry and easier to understand. Influence, Whitmarsh argues, flowed both ways, and some Christian practices had little that was Augustan about them. Wilson also flags overstatements, including a claim that the Christmas story is fiction and a line that we do not have a single word securely attributed to Jesus. He points to well-known Aramaic in the Gospels, and he finishes a bit underwhelmed: after the packaging, his reaction was, “Is that it?”
My take
God used the Roman world. “When the fullness of time had come, God sent forth his Son” (Galatians 4:4). Roads and peace were the stage, not the author. I have not sat down with Whitmarsh’s book, but I will not grant the idea that the incarnation is a useful fiction. Jesus really came, the Spirit really spread the church, and history can illuminate the setting without explaining away the miracle.
God Bless, and Use the Source!